Instead, I found a post by Bret D. Asbury, and he said a lot of really good things. I don’t agree with everything, of course. Below is a quote from his article. I found that he approached the subject of new Star Wars movies in the most open-minded, yet fan conscious way I have heard so far.
“I do not mean to suggest that Episodes I-III are cinematic masterpieces, any more so than Episodes IV-VI are. I only wish to point out that the prequels also have their moments of excellence. It follows that the sharp distinction between the original trilogy (wonderful) and the second trilogy (rubbish) is unwarranted—both are flawed, yet for long stretches remarkably entertaining space operas. Today’s kids seem to understand this better than their parents, who are often so concerned with protecting the legacy of their beloved films that they can’t appreciate the new ones. My son and his friends embrace Mace Windu as much as Luke Skywalker and are just as scared of Darth Maul as they are of Darth Vader. To them, Star Wars is a captivating, six-film succession, each episode replete with a healthy dose of quirky characters, action, and mystery.”
(Find the rest of his article here: By Bret D. Asbury)
I grew up with the Star Wars movies. When the new ones came out I was still a kid. All my opinions of them were jaded by my older siblings and my dad. I believed that “Ani” Skywalker was a bad actor because everyone else said he was.
Then I learned to screenwrite.
Have you ever listened to the dialog in the Star Wars movies, regardless of who’s speaking or the episode number? Have you ever seen Hayden Christensen in another movie besides Star Wars? What about Mark Hamill?
Then how do you know that these guys are bad actors? Mark Hamill got in a terrible car accident between A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. His face was a bit disfigured. I mean, they stopped promoting him as the pretty boy in that movie, or didn’t you notice?
Sometimes when we grow up with things we love them like newlyweds.
I suggest you re-watch the Star Wars films. Watch them like a screenwriter. You’ll see the bad dialog, plot holes and inconsistencies. You’ll see the mistakes and 70s weirdness.
(Here’s a link to interesting Star Wars info: 100 Things You Didn’t Know About The Empire Strikes Back)